POLL: Carpet or Hardwood?

Emily H

10 years ago

Do you prefer carpet or hardwood as your go-to flooring material?

VOTE and tell us about it in the comments!

Carpet

Hardwood

Featured Answer

rbcola

10 years ago

Hardwood is my love. You can always put an area rug on top if you need it!!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (171)

nehama
10 years ago
Carpet is much safer for seniors. Tile in the kitchen and bathrooms only.
detailaddict
10 years ago
We have carpet now, but our next house will have hardwoods...one of the main problems with carpet is not so much keeping them clean but the flat, "trampled" look they acquire not long after installation. Even with a thick carpet pad I have to vacuum in different directions to re-raise the nap and maintain that "fluffy" look, especially in high-traffic areas. Even more, I will NOT have flooring in our next house that emits any kind of VOC's. Our GS/Husky mix suffered a horrible autoimmune disorder last year that originated with an allergy to our new carpet. The condition is under control now and I have volcanic mineral packs set out to absorb the off-gassing, but we will not make this mistake again.
Related Discussions
Wooden floors in the kitchen??
Q
Comments (20)
I have to join this discussion of Hardwood in the kitchen. I am a little biased in this discussion because of being a tile contractor for almost 30 years. I have seen alot of hardwood kitchen floors. I have to give you the cons of putting hardwood in. Hardwood floors look great. As far as durability I am not sold. Hardwood floors look great when they are first put in. Depending on the traffic in the kitchen I give them about 4 to 5 years is when you see significant wear. I have seen alot of hardwood floors in kitchens with water damage. Now I know you think you wont have a leak from your dishwasher, refrigerator or a general plumbing leak. Well these things do happen and when it does the hardwood needs to be totally removed. Some times this is not so easy if the hardwood goes under the base cabinets. I am not saying do not put hardwood in the kitchen I think you should look at whats going to work for you. There are plenty of porcelain tiles that will give you the look of hardwood but give you the durability of a porcelain tile. Tile installed properly will last a long time. Hardwood will last but it will look warn to the point that it would need to be refinished at a cost around $2000.00 depending on the size of the room. I don't want to upset the hardwood floor lovers I have it all over my house except the bathrooms and kitchen. The floor is 20 years old 4 kids 2 dogs and still looks great. I am sure what ever you choose it will look great.
...See More
Would dark wood floor in hall leading to light oak floor kitchen work?
Q
Comments (10)
What I have always thought is, if you try to "match" an existing floor it looks like you tried and missed. When you go with something completely different, the result is yes, I wanted something different, and here it is. Especially if you lay it in a different direction. Does that make sense?
...See More
Old pine floors
Q
Comments (15)
We are in the process of filling our gaps with pine slithers (they cam in different widths) You can buy them online. You do suffer from bald/ red knees when you hammer them in and then need to chisel them down so they are flush with the rest of the floor but it really does help. What you can also order with the pine slithers is pine saw dust with resin - you mix the two up and can fill the really narrow gaps which the slithers don't fit into. If you don't mind spending the time doing this I would recommend it yourself (especially if you're worried about costs), depending how big the surface is, and then have someone in to do the sanding. The varnishing you can also do you yourself with a normal paint roller. We also recently had a quote for sanding and varnishing and I think it came to £500 for mid size living room and 3 m length hall.
...See More
Flooring Edwardian House
Q
Comments (1)
I believe you can get click and lock hardwood and bamboo planks. Also I have seen people use cork tiles on stairs quite effectively.
...See More
mwapa
10 years ago
I love carpets for my bedroom, living room and dining room, carpets are warm and cozy.
I just don't like wood.
Cindy
10 years ago
K
PRO
Ivy League Construction
10 years ago
it depends on the geographical location of the property, area of the house, amount of traffic and personal preferences.
maryan01
10 years ago
I love the feel of carpet under foot in places like the bedroom, but in work areas, i would take timber over tile any time. I find tile cold & uninviting, not to mention hard on the legs & feet if you need to be on it for any length of time. Do agree with Cancork tho'. It does look good & is softer to walk on that many hard floor options.
marieanneamell
10 years ago
I pressed carpet but I meant hardwood :-)
Debbie Thomas
10 years ago
My dog would prefer carpeting in the winter & hardwood in the summer
Peggy Hardinge
10 years ago
Hardwood. Easy to clean and lasts almost forever. Carpet gets dirty, makes dust and lasts under 10 years. It's disgusting what is in carpet after a year's time when vacuuming is all you do to it. I like hardwood with orietals or nice rugs which can be professionally cleaned.
Debbie Thomas
10 years ago
Hardwood, or carpeting, they both get dirty. If you buy a good carpet, wish I dod when my daughter started to crawl as a baby, that was 26 yrs ago. But cheap carpeting it will last 10 yrs, Invest into good carpeting, clean on a regular basis & it will last you 25 yrs.
PRO
User
10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago
Carpet is an allergy sufferer's nightmare! Prefer hardwood.
Kate
10 years ago
Hardwood! Which is fortunate because it was in every room of our home (except bathrooms, kitchen, entryway and basement).
PRO
Panache Interiors & Events, LLC
10 years ago
Hardwood! You can change the look of it instantly by adding an area rug.
Georgia Evenson
9 years ago
Hardwood or engineered.....please take my carpet!!! LOL
Louise
9 years ago
I like both but I think it really depends on the room.
PRO
User
9 years ago
Carpet. But not that cheap glue filled plastic carpet. I'm talking real carpet, woven with wool. Here's what the wood people are missing. Since the dawn of human existence people have sought to live on soft floors. First with grasses and then hides on the cave floors. This has not changed throughout history. That is until the past ten years! And what exactly has changed in the human condition that would make humans want to live on sticks & stones? At the top of the list is the cheap plastic garbage that turns ugly in a few months the floor covering industry tries to pass off as carpet. We won't even talk about nasty chemical cleaning or the warranties that are nothing but bold faced lies. Second would be marketing by the very same folk who see their customers unhappy with the cheap carpet, they're now being sold cheap wood or some composite version of wood that is mostly glue, laminated or not even wood at all, rather something that 'looks' wood like by the very same people. (( insert heavy sigh here )) No, the optimal floor covering choice for interior spaces that are occupied by humans is carpet. Nice carpet, real carpet, carpet made from natural fibers woven in a quality construction that will not only enhance the space, it will be durable, cleanable and yes, actually improve the indoor air quality and that my friends is the beauty of wool.... and it's all done naturally and ya can't beat that with a stick! ;- )
PRO
Select Hardwood Floor Co.
9 years ago
Sure I can "beat it with a stick"... and Walnut would (wood) be my "stick" of choice... haha
gracey999
9 years ago
That's really nice Select Hardwood...
PRO
German Standard Co., Ltd.
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Hardwood, when collected in a sustainable way, is a much better choice ... more durable and elegant.
Rosalind Ackerman
9 years ago
Hardwood without question. Especially with allergies like I have, it's a must. Carpet is not as easy to keep clean and I always think about what is hiding in the carpet from what is tracked in on the bottom of ones shoes. Not the healthy choice in my opinion.
PRO
J Design Group - Interior Designers Miami - Modern
9 years ago
Hardwood

J Design Group, Modern Interior Design Firm in Miami, Florida. http://www.JDesignGroup.com
brendaspaeth
9 years ago
I know I'm in the minority but I really do like carpet in a lot of areas. Bedrooms, for sure and even in a great room or family room where kids might be playing on the floor. I have a mix of all types of flooring in my home and I love it!
Debbie Thomas
9 years ago
When I go to florida, I find most homes have tile or hardwood. Up here in northern Pennsylvania I refer carpeting to keep my home warm. Our garage is directly under our ranch home, Eveb tho our home is nicely insulated, I still prefer carpeting to keep our home even warmer.
bumblebee728
9 years ago
Select Hardwood, that wood is gorgeous!!
PRO
Select Hardwood Floor Co.
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Thank you Gracey & Bumblebee!
bumblebee728
9 years ago
You're very welcome Select Hardwood :)
PRO
Kelley's Wood Floors
9 years ago
I vote wood! Why, well it's in our name, so maybe we're a little biased lol.

-It's healthier
-easier to keep clean (you can't really see the dirt that is still in your carpet after vacuuming, but you can plainly see the results of vacuuming and cleaning that hardwood) Did I mention, just wipe up any spills or animal accidents
-it can be refinished multiple times, and if you buy high quality engineered or solid wood floors then you've just invested in the only floors you'll ever need for that home - seriously! Carpet can't compete. Just think of how nasty that carpet would be after even 50 years! Wood can last well over 100 years. (We just refinished a floor that is 145 years old in Salado TX!)
-when sanding/refinishing you can completely change the color
-you can throw down any rug you want, wherever you want to. Then you can remove it and clean it thoroughly.
-it's a renewable resource and therefore it's greener, when responsibly harvested and manufactured.
- sure wool is really nice (if you're not sensitive to it), but just stick to area rugs.
- I guess I could keep going, but you get my point lol

My $.02 :)
Curt D'Onofrio
9 years ago
@Kelly's wood floors : Yep, i agree. First go with hardwood. If not to your taste, or protection purposes, you can always add area rugs. We have lots of them, as one pattern is being cleaned we use the other pattern area rugs so the wood is never left unprotected
lincolnlover
9 years ago
really depends on a lot of things but the most common answer is hardwood.
Curt D'Onofrio
9 years ago
The reason why i posted my previous comment is this: In my growing up years we had wall to wall carpeting. And i loved it. Yes, it was the 70's and it was shaggy. Then in the 90's it was removed. The hardwood beneath was then cleaned and polyurethaned. I loved that look also. The drawback ? Now i can't decide between hardwood and wall to wall carpeting. They both look good. As a compromise, we use area rugs
lindshammer
9 years ago
The medical doctor who is our allergist asked many questions in our initial environmental survey. One was: "do you have carpet in your home?" (We had a tight weave & only in bedrooms/closets) he replied: "change it to anything solid as soon as you can." Carpet can never ever ever be cleaned fully. Dust mites/pollens/dirt/fines etc. will always settle at the mat and into the pad even w the most efficient and expensive of vacuums. And in geographically humid areas if you steam clean it, it will never dry and it will be a mold spore factory.

Now to find pre-finished "healthy" hardwood...no VOC emissions is another beast if you have chemical allergies on top of dust mite/pollen...and cost exponentially increases as the health of the floor does. But still: hardwood is better than carpet for those with allergies.
pickette
9 years ago
Hardwood is my preference with area rugs made of wool to help with sound absorption.
I did some research on my own when my husband's asthma flared. It revealed dust mites do not like wool, and frequent vacuuming helps if there are pets in the house. His Respirologist sent his technician come to our home to evaluate the conditions, and he supported my findings.
Veronica Lias
9 years ago
I love carpet and realize that I am in the minority. Hardwood is so..... HARD and uncomfortable to my feet and it is LOUD, even with wearing tennis shoes. And I really don't get the whole idea of getting hardwood and then covering it up with a rug. Leaves me baffled.
gduplessis
9 years ago
When we first moved into our house, there was this awful berber carpeting in the dining and living room. Our colicky-acid-rflux twins arrived shortly after and the rooms were transformed into a playroom slash spit up land. Finally got a carpet cleaner to come out and do something about it. His exact words, "Ma'am that carpet was real dirty.' It was a great carpet to abuse and we happily ripped it out. Now the only area with carpeting is the stairs. The kids still fall down and it's a softer landing. That too will be ripped out in time. Spit up land is now our new kitchen and that poor carpet didn't have a chance.
PRO
Kootenia Homes and Remodeling
9 years ago
hardwood makes any room nicer!!
PRO
Beyond Shades
9 years ago
The hardwood will help to carry your wonderful modern look through.
Paula Lewis
9 years ago
I had carpet for years and it stayed pretty clean...for carpet.
It looked clean.
When we had the May Day Flood I knew I was not going to have carpet again.
I saw the dirt dripping out of my "clean" carpet as we cut it up and hauled it out of the house.
We could not do hardwood without replacing all the doors in the house and that was not going to happen.
So we settled on porcelain tile that looks much like wood.
When it looks clean, it is clean.
But every dog hair and piece of grass that gets tracked in seems to glow.
nehama
9 years ago
Alll well and good , hardwood. I have reached the age where I can't take a chance on sliding, slipping and falling if I'm in a hurry in the middle of the night of any other time.. Is anyone else as old as me? We have a tendancy to lose our balance. Area rugs are just as dangerous. If we have wall to wall carpet we are much safer. The emergency rooms are full of senior citizens who slip and fall and wind up with broken bones. Sorry to be gloomy but it's the truth.
Paula Lewis
9 years ago
nehama, that is being practical.
Practical is good.
nehama
9 years ago
Thank you Paula..It's good to know that someone understands.
faefrog
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
My last house had hardwoods (dark oak) throughout and I loved them. I loved that it was so CLEAN. I had lots of flexibility with area rugs which was great. You can even have rigid pad cut to go beneath your area rugs at a carpet store and then they are extra soft for laying on and the carpets stay in place better. My new house has carpet and I can't wait to replace it with hardwoods. A great thing about the oak is that it doesn't show every single thing on the floor, blond maple is awful for that. If you go to the showrooms that have been around a while, if their woods are installed on the floor, you can tell which ones wear better.
PRO
Beyond Shades
9 years ago
Concerning the hardwood floors being slippery, consider one of the engineered hand scrapped products that have a great look and a considerable amount of texture to them. That is if you love and want the look of hard wood, but are concerned about slipping in your home.
PRO
Kitchen Works LLC
9 years ago
Hardwood with radiant heated floors.
Liz H
9 years ago
The great thing about wood floors is that Persian rugs look fantastic on top of them. To me, Persians look kind of lame on wall-to-wall carpet. Anyway, I've got this thing for Persian rugs.
PRO
Koeber's Interiors: Flooring, Furniture, Windows
8 years ago
Hardwood because you can always add an area rug on top! Hardwood also raises the value of your home and it's timeless. You can refinish a hardwood where a carpet will eventually wear and need to be replaced.
PRO
Glacial Wood
8 years ago
We think anything made out of wood is beautiful. Bring nature inside.
jen seacrist
8 years ago
Hardwood definitely has a better look; however, if you have young children, carpet is worth the compromise in look for the benefit of safety. Or go with hardwood but place large area rugs down for children.
Debbie Miller
8 years ago
Besides being unable to afford the good quality hardwoods throughout my home, I have a very active and large extended family (I'm 64 and a grandmother to 20, ages 18 to 2 weeks). If I could afford regular housekeeping help, I would do hardwood or engineered wood throughout but knowing I won't dust mop every couple of days, and knowing how I hate to relax on a sofa and see dust when the light filters across the floor where I see the other side of the room (even if it's only outside a rug), the maintenance is just too high. I remember clearly when I was young and our home was built in 1958 with hardwood. My mom couldn't wait to add wall to wall carpet. The 7 of us kids were loud running through the house and my mom was constantly dusting the floors and stairs. Carpets need to be vacuumed at least once a week but not every day or two unless there is a lot of activity. So, if after work, gym workout or errands, I don't do it, I can still relax without stress. The kids can be lively without excess noise from feet. So, I am in the process of remodeling. My kitchen and entryway will have a hard, strand bamboo but the rest of the living space will have carpet. Fortunately, I don't have asthma so I can enjoy the warmth and ease of carpet. I should clean carpet more frequently than I do, but if I don't, my sanity will be OK. At this stage in life, comfort and low maintenance is extremely important to me.
PRO
Momentum Janitorial
6 years ago
Each of them does carry a list of pros and cons.Good carpets are a big investment,so it’s worth protecting them.Regularly having your carpets cleaned can significantly extend their life.Our Carpet Care service is dedicated to the use of only the safest and most effective products.Keep sharing.
PRO
Derrick Budd
6 years ago
I have reclaimed Butternut floor. I like the dings,makes floor look even older

POLL: Carpet or Hardwood?

Comments (171)

Related Discussions

COMPANY

EXPLORE HOUZZ

CONNECT WITH US