Is this how subway tile is supposed to be installed?

8 years ago

My wife and I are having our two bathrooms redone and decided on subway tile for both bath and shower. We stopped by the house today to see how things we're going and saw the subway tiles laid, but not grouted. It is our first time ever doing a remodel and are learning as we go. After seeing the subway tile today we felt completely defeated and frustrated. Can anyone tell me if this is how subway tiles are supposed to look prior to grouting? Will it look better when it is grouted and calked? We just feel like we might be getting ripped off here and the job is bad. Is this worthy of a redo?

Featured Answer

s c

8 years ago

the short answer is no, definitely not. grout won't fix a poor tile install, it will exaggerate any poor cuts and bad layout decisions like in your photos. was this done by a "handyman" or a professional tile setter?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (19)

rocknramble
Original Author
8 years ago
Thanks! I don't know the actual guy who installed it, we just talk to the general contractor and it is his business. He claims to stand by his work, but he was telling us that grout could fix the disparity in the tiles. He even took out a caulk gun and started filling in cracks? Didn't seem to make it look any better. I don't know the first thing about this stuff, but do feel like it looks pretty bad. I can't afford to pay any more money. Is it reasonable to have him redo the whole thing? I mean lines are not even. All different widths, the tiles are not flush, and some gaps are huge. I guess I thought subway tile would be easy and clean looking. Not all jagged and uneven. Thanks for your help!
Related Discussions
Need help on flooring!
Q
Comments (21)
You should have a professional installer in your area take a look at your home so you can discuss what end result you are wanting. You may need to use an engineered wood. This is still an all wood product and is much more dimensionally stable than solid wood. This is a huge advantage if you are in an older home or in the midwest where humidity levels can drastically change from season to season. A solid wood will cup or curl if humidity and moisture levels are not managed. Your installer should do a moisture test before installation to make sure the installation does not fail. All warranties will be voided if this step is not taken. Also, your transitions will need to be considered. Is the new wood floor going to butt up to tile, carpet, or vinyl? The height difference in the two products will need to be taken into consideration. You will have a greater selection of thicknesses in the engineered woods. Engineered wood should be several plys, all wood. If you choose a solid wood, the hand scraped versions are fantastic for a high traffic area with children. Hickory, Red Oak, most Brazilian Species, and even Bamboo are hard enough to take everyday traffic and still look terrific. Good luck!
...See More
Help for my Dark kitchen
Q
Comments (28)
Nothing is impossible :) Heat resistant tiles are available ,look at these for instance http://www.alibaba.com/showroom/heat-resistant-ceramic-tiles.html
...See More
Please help. I need suggestions for exterior redesign of house.
Q
Comments (15)
hello bonnielynn75 and THANK YOU! your comment put a smile on my face re the red on the interior side of the door. It IS red on the inside as well, he insisted on that when we purchased it. no one here has it red on the inside and I wanted it to be white on the inside. do you see my dilemma?;) I agree with everything you are saying, I suppose this is the reason why so far I was not 100% sure about the black for the door either, although I like black...Agree, there is too much wall and I find the house to be looking a bit 'bland' and would like to change that. I LOVE shutters, but read somewhere that you never put shutters on wide windows, so got unsure about that, too...but perhaps just the one as I stated earlier. Would the color on that shutter be the same as the door (if I ever settle on a door color)? Unfortunately window boxes are not an option as we have quite a few cats and they may be used as litter boxes;) please don't tell me to get rid of the cats;)... Regarding the stoop (entrance) : we need to add another step (made of cement) on top of the existing step: it was removed when the new door was fitted. We were thinking of putting slate tiles or something dark to match the roof, if that makes any sense.... It is porous cement so unsuitable for painting, I think. What place in Ireland did you visit, we are close to the Irish Sea in the country surrounded by sheep;)...
...See More
White counter tops
Q
Comments (8)
I have a white corian and love it. It brightened the kitchen so much. I think the Only thing you can set hot pots on is ceramic tile. I have made trivets out of pretty tiles. Go to the store and find a tile you love buy one or two and then cut felt slides that stick, like for the bottom of a chair leg or buy precut ones. These are great! I use them on lots of things. They are under my coffee pot, toaster, large cutting board, garbage bowl I keep on the counter, anything I move that's kind of big or heavy on the counter. Corian requires no sealing. Only thing that has thought about staining so far was grated carrots, or the skin gratings from carrots. But then I just worked on the spot lightly with a scotch bright pad. I saw somewhere that someone else tried a mr clean eraser n corian. Staining in my integrated white sink is zero. Installed in January 2013. I have had corian in a previous house with no problems also.
...See More
smit2380
8 years ago
It is reasonable to request that it be redone (ideally, by a more professional tile setter).
s c
8 years ago
you're absolutely right in your assumptions. I'm not sure why he would be caulking before grout, or even after in most applications.
from the photos it doesn't look like a professional install at all. I would certainly recommend that you ask him to verify his installers qualifications and whether he's capable of performing the work, if not have him take it out and refund your money so you can hire a professional tile setter. grout is not water proof, with gaps like that you will get leaks. And that's in addition to the fact that he didn't seem to do any layout to make sure he didn't have tiny pieces all over the place.
whoever your contractor hired did an excellent job of demonstrating how not to install wall tiles. it's so disappointing to see contractors who don't care about the quality of their work, it gives us all a bad name.
rocknramble
Original Author
8 years ago
Thank you so much for your time and comments. You really have helped us. We were starting to feel like we just had to settle for this because we don't know the industry. Thanks again!
rocknramble
Original Author
8 years ago
Sorry, one last thing. Is it too much to ask to expect all the lines and depth of the tiles to be the same? I guess I expected all the grout lines everywhere to be the same width? And subway tiles to be very close to each other. Also, all the tiles should lay flat against the wall at the same depth correct? They redid all the bath and shower and put all new drywall, so it should all be even. I don't understand why some bulge out, unless he just put too much glue behind some tiles?

Thanks again for your time.
Alexandra
8 years ago
All the tile is supposed to be measured and planned appropriately to avoid these weird little cuts as you show in your pictures. In addition, all the tile is supposed to be leveled, meaning it should be flat and create as flat of a surface as possible. This was done poorly. I would ask him to rip out this bad work, have him pay for the tile needed to retile, and require him that a qualified tiler does the job.
s c
8 years ago
I'm hearing a few things, drywall and glue... if this is a shower area tile should not be installed over drywall. it should be installed over a proper tile base; my tile guy uses durock and seals the joints with mesh tape to prevent cracks, then skims the entire surface with a material similar to thinset (this is referred to as a mud job) to smoothe out any imperfections in the wall. Then he applies a brush on waterproof membrane.
No drywall, sheetrock or gypboard in wet locations.
what exactly do you mean by glue? if he's setting wall tile in a wet area he should have used thinset, a material similar to mortar or cement.

To answer your questions, yes you have every reason to expect that the installer would have done layout and snapped chalk lines or used a laser to keep all the courses on a consistently level line. there should be no tiles protruding past the face of other tiles either. it sounds like he back buttered each tile and slapped it on with little regard as to the overall aesthetics of the project.

you should expect straight, consistent grout lines and flat, coplanar tile faces
Brandi Nash Hicks
8 years ago
If he has anything to say when you ask him to redo it properly, just show him this thread and he will see that it is not just you being picky, you deserve proper instillation
PRO
GN Builders L.L.C
8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
This is definitely substandard tile work,i.e uneven spacing,bad cuts, wrong cutting tools used,etc.

There is a huge difference between working with subway tile and regular tile. You have to have experience, you have to be accurate, patient, etc, because the tile is narrow and there is too many visible seams in close proximity.

Most subway tiles have built in spacers, so when installed you have a consistent 1/16" spacing all around. After the first row is laid out, you're good to go and you can just slap them up and as long as you making sure the tile is being installed level, flat and even and the backside/sides of each tile are touching, installer will maintain the consistency throughout the entire installation. You have to do that especially with subway tiles because if something gets misaligned, under/overcut, etc it will be very noticeable. True, grout will hide some imperfections but on a very small scale and the location of such imperfections should be in the less noticeable area.

You have every right to raise your concerns and have this installation rectified. He shouldn't give you a hard time and he should fix this because that is his reputation on the line.

I don't know how the rest of the job looks, but what you show in the pictures, some tiles should be removed and replaced and make sure the new tile is installed flat and level and have straight and more accurate cuts, that will get you closer to where you want to be, and also they should remove excess glue build up in between the seams in some areas, so the grout can be fully embedded into the seam.

Best of luck.
PRO
Tiles of Pompano
8 years ago
If one of our installers ever produced work like that, we would never recommend them for an install ever again. Have them replace immediately.
PRO
Cawood Architecture, PLLC
8 years ago
Professionally, I would reject the work. It was also poorly planned, with the niches not sized our located to course with the tiles with a minimum of cuts, and there are awkward cuts that probably took longer to deal with than doing properly spaced. You run the risk of his tilesetter walking off the project, but you may be better served in the long run, since the finish work is sub standard, then the rough work is probably worse.

For professional standards, you can look at the Tile Council of North America's recommendations-if you go to Laticrete's website they also have the standards free as a pdf.
suzyq53
8 years ago
Looks pretty bad. The worst part is the inset boxes where the tile doesn't line up with the surrounding walls. It will look better on the walls with white grout, but still not up to par. When I plan a job like this I measure the walls and select a tile size that works best with the dimensions to avoid all the weird cuts. Your stagger pattern makes it all look worse. If you had a decent tiler they could have shimmed it out and installed it straight for a cleaner more modern look.

At this point, if you can't get them to replace the whole thing, I would at least have them remove all the tile from the inset areas and use a smaller penny mosaic tile there so the grout lines don't have to match up. Also, they can install trim pieces around the insets.

Here are some photos to give you ideas.

Good luck. Sorry you got a bad result and hope it get fixed to your satisfaction.

Prestwick Lane · More Info
See how the tile in the inset lines up with the rest.

Transitional Master Bath · More Info
Here they use an accent tile for the insets. You could just do it in the boxes.

Flooring, bathroom and kitchen remodeling · More Info
See how the inset in surrounded by a trim piece to give it a finished look.

From Mid Century to Contemporary Master Bathroom · More Info
Different tile in the inset. Yours should go on the sides of the box as well.
Giovanna
8 years ago
Oh my! I'm not a professional but I've lived thru enough renos to recognize a bad tiling job! Get him to re-tile using a REAL tiler.
pdk920
8 years ago
I just had three walls of a claw-foot tub enclosure (1930 house) done in white subway tile. It looks a thousand times better than what you show here. You shouldn't have to settle for this amateur job. Good luck!
rocknramble
Original Author
8 years ago
Thanks, everyone, for all of your comments. It's wonderful to find such amazing support and advice from this online community. We definitely feel more empowered to assert our opinions and ask for a redo/repair. We have already expressed to our contractor that this is unacceptable work, and that it needs to be remedied. He agreed, but we will see to what degree when we meet on Monday.

I think what's most frustrating is that when we pointed out these flaws initially, our contractor brushed it off as if they were small imperfections that could be easily resolved with some grout and caulk. This worries us in regard to his level of acceptable quality workmanship. We still have hardwood floors that he is going to install, and we are wondering if this kind of mentality will be applied to that process, as well.

We'll keep everyone posted! Hopefully, things don't turn ugly, and our contractor does what he needs to do to uphold his reputation. He touts that he's been in the business for over two decades because he does good work and will do what it takes to make things right.

Just another question - any ideas how thick the spacing should be between the bathtub and tiling or between a kitchen countertop and backsplash? I know that when surface planes change in direction, they are supposed to be caulked at the joint. I'm looking at our backsplash install in the kitchen, and the tiles have been set right on top of the countertops - not sure how any caulk could be applied in that spacing. Is this normal?

Thanks again, everyone!
PRO
GN Builders L.L.C
8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
For interior installation is not more than a 1/4" and never less than 1/8" spacing.
suzyq53
8 years ago
Yes they usually set the counter tops and then the backsplash goes on top.
Tammy Lawhorn
8 years ago
This is awful!! I wouldn't accept this and I would make sure he gets another installer the second time around. If he refuses then get a new contractor!!

Is this how subway tile is supposed to be installed?

s c

Comments (19)

rocknramble
Original Author

Related Discussions

smit2380

s c

rocknramble
Original Author

rocknramble
Original Author

Alexandra

s c

Brandi Nash Hicks

GN Builders L.L.C

Tiles of Pompano

Cawood Architecture, PLLC

suzyq53

Giovanna

pdk920

rocknramble
Original Author

GN Builders L.L.C

suzyq53

Tammy Lawhorn

COMPANY

EXPLORE HOUZZ

CONNECT WITH US

Is this how subway tile is supposed to be installed?

Comments (19)

rocknrambleOriginal Author

Related Discussions

rocknrambleOriginal Author

rocknrambleOriginal Author

rocknrambleOriginal Author

COMPANY

EXPLORE HOUZZ

CONNECT WITH US

rocknramble
Original Author

rocknramble
Original Author

rocknramble
Original Author

rocknramble
Original Author