Wine cooler differences?

6 years ago

Looking to install one of these as part of a kitchen remodel and I was blown away at the price difference between them. These start at around $2-300 and go up to $3-4000 for the size that I want. What is with the crazy price range for what is effectively a mini-fridge? Yeah I know it has some additional features like dual-zone setup and such but how do I decide what is paying extra for good quality manufacturing/reliability vs. brand name and hype?

Featured Answer

PRO

Wine Cellar Specialists

6 years ago

Generally, it's like a car. A Toyota Corolla and an Audi A6 virtually do the same thing, aren't that different in function, and both will get you from point A to point B. Some would even argue that the Corolla works better, and some would say the A6 works better. It seems to depend on opinion and experience. Yet, one is tens of thousands more expensive than the other. Many factors go into this, like the badge on the vehicle, the money spent to ship the parts to your country, the extra bells and whistles inside the car and inside the engine, and the aesthetics. In the end, it simply depends on what you want out of the product. If you just want a good wine cooler that does the job, the low-end wine coolers may work just fine and do what you need them to do, like a Corolla. If you want some extra bells and whistles, more high-quality materials, a fancier name brand, and some additional useful functions, go for a higher priced wine cooler. Look up reviews on certain wine coolers and see what others' experiences are.

I hope my novel helped clear something up for you. Good luck!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (27)

Ron Natalie
6 years ago
The real issue is what you intend to do with it. If you're just keeping the wine at serving temperature for a month or less, it makes little difference. By the one that looks the nicest for you at the price.

If you're going for a larger one that you are going to "cellar" wine in, you'd be better to get a unit designed for that.

As for whether you want dual zone or not really depends what you like and what you are drinking. Ideal serving temperature varies by wine variety (and even then despite what people tell you, it's largely a matter of personal taste).
Scott MacDonald
Original Author
6 years ago
@Ron Natalie - Why does it matter how long you intend to keep wine in it? We've had home refrigeration figured out for almost 100 years now, it's not super complicated, you choose a target temp and the unit maintains that temp, the compressor kicking in when it needs to. What does a $3000 unit do that a $300 unit does not that would effect how long I intend to keep my wine in it? If it is snooty expensive French wine does it go bad when it detects it is in a cheaper unit?
Related Discussions
Make my room more family friendly
Q
Comments (42)
Hi Janis Unfortunately I am not in the Boston area - I live in Ireland! Yes there are red items in 3 of the main rooms, the kitchen, sitting room and tv room (library) - although we have pared those back now and it's not as overwhelming. thanks for all your help everyone, i really feel like it's made a big difference and am excited to finish the tv room and then refresh the play room. do you think I should move the piano to the sitting room? and would the jazz painting work in the tv room? speak later, thanks!
...See More
Make my room more impressive
Q
Comments (127)
Lots of ideas....couldn't resist adding my two cents. i copied your photos and did a little cut and paste- it's messy, but hopefully gets the main idea across. i'd put your sofa in front of the large book case, chair by the fireplace, tv on the stand on the wall opposite the fireplace - so you can either look at the fire or the tv. Someone suggested using frames of one color for your photos - an inexpensive way to do that would be to spray paint them all a dark color-black goes with everything. Since your shelves are a medium tone wood, display things that are dark or light so that they contrast against the wood. Limiting your display items pallette to a few values usually helps to unify things. (I think that's why so many people want to paint the shelves or put inserts in the back to help your nice things read more clearly...some get lost). If you want to "splurge" -you may consider having a carpenter make a few solid tall cabinet doors to provide a visual break in the shelving. I'm showing 3 doors - 1 on the right side of the fireplace and 2 on the left to leave two open vertical shelves for display on each side - with things arranged to frame the fireplace as the focal point. To add some height to your big vases, consider stacking some books beneath them. Enjoy experimenting untill you get something you're happy with - good luck!
...See More
Kitchen re-decoration
Q
Comments (16)
Thanks for the explanation. Try a wall that is drawers up to waist high, cupboards above that. YOu can add pull-out cutting boards at waist height so that you can put things there when unpacking groceries and putting things away in the cabinets and drawers: Drawers will help but they will not increase storage space by a factor of two. You could also add drawers where the microwave is now and continue to keep the microwave on top. Here is another wall of wood cabinets: Although it will not solve your storage problem, I recommend that you pull everything out of the cabinets and drawers, one drawer or shelf at a time. Be flexible about storing things elsewhere while the children are very small. Or discarding "aspirational cooking" implements (egg slicers, orange zesters, martini shakers. lobster-shaped gelatin molds) that just haven't been used in years. Families with children tend to accumulate an enormous amount of plastic stuff. In six months or a year, they will need different plastic stuff!
...See More
Hi there , looking at house with north east facing garden, has anyone
Q
Comments (327)
How will you pose for your Miss Photogenic photo op? Will you go with the Carmen Miranda fruit bowl tiara? Or would the Easter egg thingamadooeys suffice? Decisions, decisions..... Maybe Grover could photo shop each one with your dress so we can decide? We wouldn't want to break any decorating rules because we do have our reputations to uphold. LOLOLOLOLOL
...See More
User
6 years ago
Things I looked for: no vibration, humidity range, temperature range, wine magazine reviews.

A $300 model usually holds a case or so, a $3,000 model usually holds 200-300 bottles.
Scott MacDonald
Original Author
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
@Jim Mat - no, sadly it is not so. I'm not comparing a 20 bottle model to a 300 bottle model, I'm comparing apples to apples.

this is a 26 bottle built-in dual zone model, it is $600

https://www.winecoolerdirect.com/edgestar-26-bottle-dual-zone-built-in-wine-cooler/CWR262DZ.html

this is a 32 bottle built-in dual zone model, it is $4000+

https://www.winecoolerdirect.com/perlick-hp24do-3-3r-outdoor-dual-wine-reserve-steel-glass-right/HP24DO-3-3R.html
User
6 years ago
$600 model is for inside your house installation. $4,000 model is for installation outside your house.
Scott MacDonald
Original Author
6 years ago
@Jim Mat - Outside your house??? Why would you keep your wine outside, wouldn't the unit get ruined by weather?

I guess the point of my question is that I can understand there's a range of prices for low end models vs high end...but this is kinda ridiculous that they're selling glorified mini fridges for 4k, so I assumed I had to be missing something?
mishmosh
6 years ago
Not sure where you are looking but a mini-fridge type wine cooler is usually well under $1000. Those are for the undercounter variety that has venting at the front and a cooling fan. Regular mini-fridges have coils in the rear which would not be good for a built-in installation.

I believe our 19" undercounter refridgerator costs $700. A regular minifridge would cost about $200. Just like anything, I bet you could find one that was over $1000 for the well heeled. Not any different from a $50 watch or a $50k watch...both tell the time.
2ManyDiversions
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
The difference is Perlick, which are more expensive than a less recognized brand last longer, are better built, or so I've been told. I don't think they are of the same quality as a Sub Zero wine cooler. There are all kinds, and prices. Frankly, this is one appliance we will skimp on. We've had a cheap wine cooler that's lasted us for some time now, and it keeps the temps correct. It's quite, doesn't vibrate, and is dual zone. It won't fit in our new kitchen, but we'll go with something less costly to replace should the new one break.
Steve J
6 years ago
I have a dual zone wine fridge, and IMHO, i’d never buy a dual zone again. I do have a kenmore unit that is on the lower end of the spectrum so I’m sure that has something to do with it. Most wine is ideally stored at 55 degrees so if your goal is log term storage, a dual zone doesnt offer you a lot. You can ramp down the temp for whites before parties or serving, or you can also just put those bottles in your fridge or outside depending on temp. My unit doesnt monitor or adjust humidity, it just cools and evaporates a plastic container so i have to keep filling it. Because my unit is noisy, I tend to unplug it periodically at times and forget about the water tub. Let it sit long enough with the door closed and it turns into mold all over the inside of the fridge (yes, it happened). Prepare to maintain your fridge, or spend more up front and buy a better unit. Best of luck with your search.
2ManyDiversions
6 years ago
Wine Cellar Specialists, I'd give you 3 'likes' if I could. I hope the OP reads your short novella (honestly, it's not that long) - most clearly spelled out, even-handed explanation I'll probably ever read. Kudos.
Scott MacDonald
Original Author
6 years ago
@Wine Cellar Specialists sigh...I think you're still missing the point of the question. Lets use the analogy you put forward with cars because I think its a good idea...but first you're numbers are way off. A Corolla is $18,500 and an A6 is $50,000. So the Audi costs about 2.5 times what the Corolla does so that's not an accurate representaion, you need something that is 8-10 times as much so lets say a Porsche 911 Turbo which goes for about $182,000.

If I'm comparing those 2 vehicles I can see REAL tangible differences between the two:

-The 911 has 540HP and will do 0-60 in 2.9 sec, it has a top speed of 198 mph and is AWD

-The Corolla has 132HP, does 0-60 in 9.5 sec and has a top speed of 111 mph, it does not have AWD

Is that worth 10 times as much? Possibly, if those things are important to you, but the point to take home is that these are actual measurable differences I can point to and present an argument justifying the extra expense. So far with the wine coolers, I've not heard what the $4000 ones do that the $500 ones do not. That's the thrust of the question.
Anthony C
6 years ago
I had the same issues. We got this one

Silhouette 24" Dual Zone French Door Wine Storage - 42 Bottle Capacity - Stainless Steel
Steve J
6 years ago
Snafu, you’re obviously a car person, so those measurable differences will mean more to you likely than wine fridge stats. For the expensive wine fridges, you’re generally getting more capacity, more efficient motors, better insulation and glass for efficiency, better motor mounts for little or no vibration which is bad for wine, hydrometers to monitor humidity, alarms to detect temp/humidity issues, more modular racks, better warranties, a better fit and finish, and last but not least, more often built to widstand the harsher environment of being shoved into a cabinet or tight closet.
mishmosh
6 years ago
It's pretty obvious what the differences are between $500 and $4000 wine fridges. It's all a matter of what you value and what your budget is. Not worth arguing.
stevep2005
6 years ago
The Perlick Outdoor Dual-Zone Wine fridge you zeroed in on is a bit of an outlier, designed to operate properly outdoors, you know, where it can be 100 or -10 degrees. It's for folks with fancy outdoor kitchens and big budgets. Regular refrigerators don't operate properly under those temperature conditions or in the elements.

I too was debating installing a beverage fridge several years back and was confused by the huge variance in price for comparable size units. I ended up bailing on the idea because we are also big craft beer drinkers, and beverage fridge designs don't accommodate craft beer bottle sizes well at all. Would not have been worth taking up the cabinet space, the noise, or the cost for just a handful of chilled bottles. Instead I got a $200 apartment fridge for the garage with far more flexibility and capacity, and couldn't be happier.

Good luck on your search.
kitchengirl
6 years ago
Consider the quality of the motor, its efficiency and insulation, how well the racks function (or don't), vibration and humidity. I have read many reviews of inexpensive wine fridges dying within 5 years. While I don't have first hand experience with it, I don't want to put a large metal & plastic box on the curb after 5 years... I did steer clear of the overly costly high-end fridge manufacturers' wine fridges, but I opted to spend more on a Eurocave for its engineering and insulation.
nycbluedevil_gw
6 years ago
I have expensive appliances in both of my kitchens (Subzero, Miele, Blue Star, etc.). But I didn’t see the point in spending 3k for a wine fridge in either kitchen. I went with a Uline that stores about 48 bottles for less than half the price. I have had them for several years and have been quite pleased.
kitchengirl
6 years ago
Hey bluedevil, a shout out from the upper MW.
kitchengirl
6 years ago
...from another BD
nycbluedevil_gw
6 years ago
Hey KG—saw you got pounded with snow! We have family in Michigan and they are digging out. OP—sorry to hijack your thread:-)
kitchengirl
6 years ago
Yes, the most we've experienced in 4 years here -- still manageable, except for SoCal doggie's paws can't manage below 12°. She has finally learned to run outside and run back in! End of off-topic! Sorry to all!
2ManyDiversions
6 years ago
nycbluedevil_gw, that's the route we're taking with our wine cooler as well... high end appliances but the built in wine cooler will be a Uline or something along those lines, and cheaply replaceable (same size, so built in doesn't scare me).
Scott MacDonald
Original Author
6 years ago
@kitchengirl - I hear you and I looked at the eurocaves myself and honestly for a 'proper' wine cellar, that's 100% the way to go. Once we get around to doing the basement that's what I'll put in for long term storage and aging. For the kitchen though, I think of it more as a short term storage solution...bottles you've pulled out that are ready to drink you want to have on hand for guests/dinner etc

@nycbluedevil_gw - Which Uline did you go with? They've come recommended from a couple people so I'm strongly considering them. Seems like just the right balance of quality to price maybe?
kitchengirl
6 years ago
snafu, I looked extensively, and planned on a full-size one temp unit to go in our mudroom, which is immediately adjacent to the kitchen (to keep the heat out of the pantry and did not want to 'feature' the wine unit). But in the end, I chose the wine/beverage 2-temp model from Eurocave, as it will allow us to use 1/4 of the unit for all the other bulky drinks that would clutter up our main fridge. Never thought I would choose a 2 temperature model, but it seemed to solve our situation best, and I dream of an uncluttered main fridge!
kitchengirl
6 years ago
Uline is a high quality product, IMHO. We found an under-counter model at Nebraska Furniture Mart on closeout, so we are using that in our rec room bar, as it cools down to the low-mid 30's, unlike some other brands -- good for beer, soda, water, etc.
nycbluedevil_gw
6 years ago
I think I got the 1175WC.

Wine cooler differences?

Wine Cellar Specialists

Comments (27)

Ron Natalie

Scott MacDonald
Original Author

Related Discussions

User

Scott MacDonald
Original Author

User

Scott MacDonald
Original Author

mishmosh

2ManyDiversions

Steve J

2ManyDiversions

Scott MacDonald
Original Author

Anthony C

Steve J

mishmosh

stevep2005

kitchengirl

nycbluedevil_gw

kitchengirl

kitchengirl

nycbluedevil_gw

kitchengirl

2ManyDiversions

Scott MacDonald
Original Author

kitchengirl

kitchengirl

nycbluedevil_gw

COMPANY

EXPLORE HOUZZ

CONNECT WITH US

Wine cooler differences?

Comments (27)

Scott MacDonaldOriginal Author

Related Discussions

Scott MacDonaldOriginal Author

Scott MacDonaldOriginal Author

Scott MacDonaldOriginal Author

Scott MacDonaldOriginal Author

COMPANY

EXPLORE HOUZZ

CONNECT WITH US

Scott MacDonald
Original Author

Scott MacDonald
Original Author

Scott MacDonald
Original Author

Scott MacDonald
Original Author

Scott MacDonald
Original Author