Landmark Shingles: Burnt Sienna or Black

4 months ago

last modified: 4 months ago

Struggling to decide between what is apparently the only two color options available per my roofer, Burnt Sienna or Moire Black. I'd have preferred red to go with the brick trim and give it a Santa Barbara vibe, but I guess we only have these two color options. I don't think either are great with current wall and trim colors, but to me the black has some versatility in terms of painting over the brick trim dark for a clean, modern look (and minimal add'l cost). Conversely, even though it's a warm tone like red, I don't think Burnt Sienna (a) quite matches the red brick trim, nor (b) goes well against a cool-toned bright white. What do you think in terms of aesthetics, and/or curb appeal?

Keep in mind I'd paint the door to match.

Current Old Roof:

Landmark Burnt Sienna:

Landmark Moire Black:

Moire Black with trim painted dark:

Moire Black with a mix of trim painted white and dark:

Featured Answer

houssaon

4 months ago

Whatever color you go with, please don't paint the red tile (bricks). They are part of the charm of the house and I think they will work with any roof color. I prefer the Burnt Sienna. I do like the suggestion of matching the grout color if you do paint the siding for a softer look.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (17)

PRO
Beth H. :
4 months ago
last modified: 4 months ago
where are you located?

Is there any chance you can go w/the cement tiles? or, if your roof isn't rated for that load, the terra cotta spanish style tiles. It's perfect for that style of home.

It would match your brick

I love everything else about this front porch/door area too.

I'd also sand and refinish your wood fence. sand off the gray if you can, and coat it w/a good stain/varnish. This one is mine

My home isn't as 'spanish' as yours, more mediterranean, but I did the cement tiles in a charcoal gray.

or redo it

If you must stick w/the shingles, go w/the black
Thomas Schmitt
Original Author
4 months ago
Thanks Beth, I'm in Denver. I don't think I could afford terracotta tiles, though they would be perfect. I'm afraid it's just the shingles.
millworkman
4 months ago
" Struggling to decide between what is apparently the only two color options available per my roofer, "

What is his reasoning for that?
Thomas Schmitt thanked millworkman
cat_ky
4 months ago
Why would a roofer only have 2 colors to pick from. Something not quite right there. If you plan on keeping the rusty red, I would pick the burnt sienna because, it seems to go well with the brickish color red.
PRO
Lori A. Sawaya
4 months ago
Burnt Sienna is an orange roof, there isn't anything brown about it.

Moire Black all day long.

Paint the house the same color as the grout between the brick and it's classically pulled together without being an overt color schemed color scheme. Going forward, practically all of color space is your oyster for front door colors and landscaping.
acm
4 months ago
sienna
PRO
BeverlyFLADeziner
4 months ago
last modified: 4 months ago
What kind of roofer only has two choices for a roof? That's a big red flag IMO.

A Hexagonal asphalt shingle would have looked appropriate on your Craftsman style home.
Thomas Schmitt
Original Author
4 months ago
Roofer explained lack of color options are due to supply shortages among manufacturer, and I had heard similar from other roofers who provided quotes. Maybe I need to enquire directly with the manufacturer myself.

Interesting thought about hexagonal shingles...
la_la Girl
4 months ago
^^^ well said
ptreckel
4 months ago
Find another roofer.
PRO
Beth H. :
4 months ago
last modified: 4 months ago
since you're in denver, forget the clay tiles. I don't think they're rated for freezing temps.

you could opt for the cement tiles though. why not get a price on them? just for grins. if you're going to be in that house for a long time, you'll never have to replace them in your lifetime. (what's the life of asphalt? 15-20? do the math and see which works out best)

we have those cement tiles in my neighborhood going on 43 yrs. (I redid mine because I went w/a diff color theme) Check w/Eagle Roofing and Boral roof. they will tell you which materials are avail in your area of the country.

if you go w/the lighter roof, consider painting the fascia black. (and some trim) i did a quick mock up here for you. and a new cedar gate.
Thomas Schmitt thanked Beth H. :
PRO
Lori A. Sawaya
4 months ago
last modified: 4 months ago
Roofer explained lack of color options are due to supply shortages among manufacturer,

My crystal color ball says that's the reason Burnt Sienna is available - it's what's still in stock. They're running a 'basic black' option until they can run more colors.

I would ask the roofer for addresses that have BS. Drive by more than one. Because it is orange and it will dictate every other exterior choice for 30 years.
PRO
Emily’s Interiors
4 months ago
Moire Black is a great choice. Agree with @houssaon about the brick. It is charming. Maybe just a cleanup?
wdccruise
4 months ago
last modified: 4 months ago
Energy Star Cool Roofs (information)
- Cool Roof Directory: GAF*
- Cool Roof Directory: Owens Corning*
-----
-----

*CRRC RATED PRODUCTS DIRECTORY USER GUIDE, LEARN ABOUT COOL ROOFS AND WALLS
J Mig
4 months ago
We have a bunch of burnt sienna roofs here in Albuquerque. And they are really ugly. very rarely do they go with whatever is on the façade of the house, whether it is brick or stucco. I feel like you can do better.
ker9
4 months ago
FYI, Florida is still recovering from massive damage due to Hurricane Ian, which means there are an abnormally large number of roofs being replaced with shingle, tile, metal, etc. It is probably placing additional burden on an already strained supply chain. As a matter of fact, my damaged roof is being torn off right now. Landfall occurred 9/28/22.