Design Debate: Are you FOR or AGAINST hanging a TV over a fireplace?

Mitchell Parker

7 years ago

Design Debate: Is It OK to Hang the TV Over the Fireplace? · More Info

Some designers say go for it; others say no way. Which side of history are you on?

Be sure to check out our design debate conversation on this topic, too!

For

Against

Featured Answer

sambo556

7 years ago

May I suggest another option? Get rid of the television altogether. There isn't anything worth watching anyway.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (133)

L W
7 years ago
In my condominium complex nearly everyone with a fireplace has a TV mounted over it. I don't. Just don't like the look of an up to 60 inch "black hole" hovering over the fireplace as you view programs with your head tilted up as if you were sitting in the first row of an IMax movie theater. I have a medium sized (40 inch) TV which fits perfectly in a space next to the fireplace. As for the mantel, my husband and I enjoy decorating it for each season.
pvkshouse
7 years ago
Artwork is best viewed when the center is at eye-level...or so I've read for years. When you're sitting, eye-level drops. Watching a TV screen placed over a fireplace is probably terrific for people who love sitting in the first row of a movie theatre...but not my cup of tea. And then, there's the aesthetics....
Related Discussions
Make my room more impressive
Q
Comments (127)
Lots of ideas....couldn't resist adding my two cents. i copied your photos and did a little cut and paste- it's messy, but hopefully gets the main idea across. i'd put your sofa in front of the large book case, chair by the fireplace, tv on the stand on the wall opposite the fireplace - so you can either look at the fire or the tv. Someone suggested using frames of one color for your photos - an inexpensive way to do that would be to spray paint them all a dark color-black goes with everything. Since your shelves are a medium tone wood, display things that are dark or light so that they contrast against the wood. Limiting your display items pallette to a few values usually helps to unify things. (I think that's why so many people want to paint the shelves or put inserts in the back to help your nice things read more clearly...some get lost). If you want to "splurge" -you may consider having a carpenter make a few solid tall cabinet doors to provide a visual break in the shelving. I'm showing 3 doors - 1 on the right side of the fireplace and 2 on the left to leave two open vertical shelves for display on each side - with things arranged to frame the fireplace as the focal point. To add some height to your big vases, consider stacking some books beneath them. Enjoy experimenting untill you get something you're happy with - good luck!
...See More
New kitchen, but just not working.
Q
Comments (448)
fragle0 ... congratulations on the new addition to your family. Have been following your lovely changes. You probably won't have time to work on the decor for a while. Just wanted to suggest that you try pulling the nesting tables forward to be more in line with front of the chairs & placing your floor lamp to the back of them. This will give a bit more light at night for reading in that area.Also switching the plant by the fireplace & the one on the corner by the sofa.
...See More
Anyone? Help please?!
Q
Comments (9)
Hi S, mirrors are effective when they are reflecting something visually interesting, like the view from an opposite window to the outdoors, or when used to create the illusion of additional space. The mirror in this picture does neither of those things. With the TV removed from the corner, there is more room for the window treatments to fill the corner properly (right now they look a bit squished), and it would be fine to leave it bare, or put a low accessory item in the corner, like a sculpture or a potted tree (not too tall!). As for the rug and table, there are 3 ways you can go: since the striped wallpaper and the floors are so neutral already, you can afford to add some color into the room with the rug. With a colorful or patterned rug, a clear glass table top would be good, because it allows you to see the rug. In that instance, the rug becomes the focal point of your furniture group. If you want to keep the rug very neutral too, then a solid table top is good (in an interesting material- maybe wood or stone). In that case, the table becomes the focal point of your furniture group. Lastly, if you want a neutral rug and a transparent table top, I would be sure to add some color or pattern to your seating- either the sofas themselves or throw pillows on the sofas, to inject some energy and keep the whole room from feeling too bland.
...See More
Need help for my Living Rooom
Q
Comments (31)
Thanks Decoenthusiaste! Yes that sofa is unavailable here and hard to find anything similar in local stores, but I may have one made up! So yes I’m using the images you post as inspiration and hope to find similar items here, I also love the grey Scandanavian sofa ideas you had earlier, and will use them as inspiration to get a lighter replacement. The blind on my window is screwed in place, but I could easily replace it with something that would let in more light, like the top down blinds (which are new to me!). I’m really glad no one has thought the absence of curtains an issue, as light is scarce here & I prefer the no curtains look. I do agree we should move the car to another part of our drive to get a nicer view out. A radiator cover that could double as a shelf would work well I think, I love the bespoke one, how cool! Also good to find out that you can get ones that allow the heat to rise. Re the music centre, I might replace with an iPod doc with speakers as Glo kindly suggested, In meantime I might cover it (and the dreaded TV!) with a piece of framed art leaning from the floor, aware that’ll be another competing focal point, but hopefully a nicer one! Thanks a lot for the tip re dimensions for a piece of art over the sofa and a coffee table, both of which are on my list to get, I would’ve had no clue re this and it’s fantastic to discover that there are certain rules which, if you apply them, can make your room work visually! Thanks again for the brilliant advice, I really appreciate it.
...See More
PRO
Studio NOO Design
7 years ago
Tv above fireplace is ALWAYS to high...and who wants to see a tv there anyways !
Liz
7 years ago
I really liked the designs where the tv was not above the fireplace, but IMHO many family rooms would need to be redesigned to accommodate these designs unless they are large. Without enough space for entertainment centers, many rooms simply do not have a better location for their large flat screen TVs than above their fireplaces. Also, with smart TVs comes the ability to display beautiful photography or artwork above your fireplace as well. It boils down to space and budget limitations, and of course, personal preference.
PRO
cryder construction
7 years ago
i voted for. our tv sits on the mantle above a fireplace insert. everyone that has come into this house has loved our set up...man or woman. the neck strain thing is ridiculous, unless you are up to close to the tv. As Mr. Clawson pointed out, in a recliner it is BETTER. So, alot depends on the size of the room and furniture placement....just one of many things that affect a families decision on where to place the tv. Its a matter of personal opinion, wall space, size of the room...etc. when it comes to tv placement.
And I am in construction business Ms Susan Arlitt, and can design any room or house as good or better than any designer. All I need to know is a general idea of what a person wants. Simply put, it comes down to what the customer wants for a "designer" or contractor to get it right. Your notion that a designer has more ability to layout a room is ridiculous as it is the customers idea of the room that is being brought to life, and all a designer can do is offer suggestions. And you may need therapy for some kind of anger issue it sounds like, and talk about arrogance! lol
Tribbletrouble44152k7 Trek
7 years ago
Peace, folks!
pvkshouse
7 years ago
Spot on!
lynartist
7 years ago
There should have been an other box to check! I never say never , ever! Every home is different, and everyone's situation is too! We are living in modern times and our homes should meet today's needs . They are not museums. While it may be beautiful to have an accessorized fireplace in an older home it just might not be practical either! If the room is to small , has too many windows or doors you might not have any choice. While everyone is screaming "Don't put the tv over the fireplace"! The poor OP is stuck with it balancing on a TV tray on the side which looks just awful! Hmmm, I'm often left wondering if a fireplace is worth all the trouble!
D C
7 years ago
They do not discuss having paintings that lift up to expose the TV underneath. This option allows for both a lovely look of a traditional fireplace yet having a TV in the living room. There are also mirrors which allow the TV screen to be seen behind it when on and roll up paintings. Both points of view seem to be behind the times.
Dan Keuter
7 years ago
I agree! See my comment from Sunday at 10:08 AM, You can have both with ARTV Mount. ARTV Mount Video

Dan Keuter
Momof5x
7 years ago
Two reasons I am against:

1. Too high.

2. Electric and Fire close to each other doesn't go with me.
sails365
7 years ago
We love fireplaces.We have had a TV over the fireplace ever since thin screens came out. We have a split piece of artwork that covers the TV when its not being viewed. The art work is hinged and opens for viewing.
The TV's mounting bracket is articulated for comfortable viewing.

One of the examples you displayed in the debate was a long horizontal tube. Viewing a long gas tube is so far from a real fire that you might as well turn on the burners on your kitchen gas stove and watch that. How's that for romance. Some high quality gas burners come close to a wood burning fire, but many clearly fall short.
Karen Nichols
7 years ago
It depends on each individual home and homeowner. For us, we're pretty much limited to the fireplace wall because one wall is all glass and the facing walls have large art pieces that play across the room at each other. Even if it weren't for the art, we would want to put an entertainment cabinet on either of those two walls because it breaks up the wall height (30ft). I'd prefer to keep the TV hidden away, but until we can figure out how to make that happen, the TV remains above the fireplace and the entertainment center cabinet is in the formal living room.

You put it where it works for you.
silentfilmfan
7 years ago
If television viewing is your main priority, then maybe it's time to get rid of the fireplace. Use your picture in picture feature on that smart TV for a fireplace. And aren't we more 'glued' to our phones than anything else?
willozwisp
7 years ago
No TV, so moot point for me. Watch TV or Fire in fireplace? Guess I am too pragmatic. Figure the heat radiating from the chimney and any blowback of smoke or soot would not be good for electronics or the new screens. Ash is an abrasive.
joelegnater
7 years ago
If it makes sense in your room then do it....I have both a living and family room and only one tv in the house....I put it over the fireplace but is still not the focus of the room because of the pool...I really like it there and I can watch while making dinner or doing anything else in my multipurpose kitchen/family/breakfast room. Wouldn't have it any other way....
Kitchen Ideas · More Info
jtalk4456
7 years ago
Over a fake fireplace sure
Maria McNulty
7 years ago
Never understood the idea. Too high for comfort. Takes away from the actual fireplace (much like crowded mantles do). When it is not on, its just a black box.
jtalk4456
7 years ago
depends on how you build it. I agree with you in many instances I've seen though.
orangebeach2015
7 years ago
I absolutely HATE the TV over the fireplace. Practically, it is very uncomfortable. More importantly, as Tamara Leicester mentioned, the TV does not need to be the center of attention for any home. I cringe as I witness America bow down daily before the "god" of television. Aesthetically, at best it speaks of low imagination. Your home should reflect your interests, beliefs and joys. Put up that art you love! Make a collage of things that make you happy. Show that sculpture! Arrange your photographs. Do SOMETHING beside that television!
Lu Lyon
7 years ago
I agree, sails365, with your view of the long horizontal blue flame, which is somehow supposed to be viewed as a fireplace. To me, they look like an aquarium after the Apocalypse. Those videos of traditional fireplaces (popular at Christmastime) are more interesting to contemplate.
Monica
7 years ago
I've lived in 3 house in the last 10 years that have/had fireplaces. If I can find another place for the TV I have. I feel like the TV takes away from the special evening and ambience a fire creates. And I don't always looking at a fireplace unless there is a fire in it. So I'll keep them separate - unless there is just no other way to work it into the room.
PRO
Advantage Audio Video Services
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
As a Custom Audio Video Installation Specialist for 15 years, I have always and will remain to support my client's decision in the choice. I always educate them before the installation process begins and offer multiple solutions for mounting and disguising the TV. There are companies like Seura & Visionart that specialize in hiding while not in use. Dynamic Mounting (pictured) for lowering to a suitable height when in use. Custom cabinetry might also be an option for gas-log fireplaces as long as they meet code*.
Advantage Audio Video Services
graycern
7 years ago
A TV over the fireplace would not work in our house. Our mantle is about 5 ft high, the TV would be too high to watch comfortably. When we had a TV, we had it on a low TV stand that was perfect height for viewing from the couch.
Mitra Moini
7 years ago
I'm against any television in the house, period! Haven't watched it in more than 10 years and don't miss it.
templeofm
7 years ago
I have had tv's over fire places, they are always placed too hight for comfortable viewing, so no, don't do it.
Kathy
7 years ago
I don't think it is a yes or no. Every case is different. Sometimes there is no option. If it is a wood burning fireplace you have to check the heat factor. Otherwise I think it is up to each individual case.
creatureofchaos
7 years ago
TVs are ugly. Fireplaces are pretty. The math - even without concerns about viewing height/distance - is simple.

I don't want to see a TV *anywhere* unless it's turned on and showing something I want to watch. TVs are ugly. Mine are hidden even in my family/media room (lift cabinet, doors).
Judy Hotchkiss
7 years ago
Television is a personal choice. creatureofchaos solved the issue for themselves in a way I would have suggested--hide it unless you are using it. For others, it is NOT an issue.

I'd never put mine over a mantle because it unbalances that side of the room. (probably too high AND could be damaged by heavy use of a fireplace). I've also mostly lived in old houses where the firebox and the mantle are rather high. Modern houses have lower fireboxes so placement may indeed work, especially in new spaces with open plans and very little wall space.

I'm about to hang one of mine centered on the framing of white built in bookcases which have a right and left section. I "wish" TV frame was white or silver. It isn't. But at least it will be the spot's focal point, balanced in its placement AND functional for our needs. Getting electric to it may be the bigger issue!
PRO
AVOLIER
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
Evolution of the fireplace and the television is here.
Avolier Fireplace Theater · More Info
Nothing a fireplace can do the Audiolier.com can't do better. Smell, heat, sound and fire. It's totally safe. Best fires and they can be changed. Why all the headaches of the fireplace and the maintenance. Evolution of the fireplace and the HDTV is coming and will become the focal point of today's home. It's a thought. Model shown is 70" television.
PRO
AVOLIER
7 years ago
Televisions in the home are a fact of life. And the large HDTV are a modern miracle connected to the Internet. To enjoy the the television you must have good sound system and that is a big problem. The other problem is the television must be mounted so that it at eye level viewing to be enjoyed. The big problem with the television it's not decorative like everything in the room. The solution is to redefine the fireplace and make the television the focal point. It can be done.
sjka111
7 years ago
I have a beautiful painting abovey fireplace . Everyone that comes in loves my home. The warmth of the fire and the beauty of the art does it all
PRO
Mint Kitchen Group
7 years ago
It depends on the size and the look of the space.
eightpondfarm
7 years ago
i would spend more time downstairs if allowed a TV over the fireplace....but alas, it's verboten. Ergo, i hang out in the 'dog room' or bedroom, two places where there is a tv.
kenduce
7 years ago
Why NOT BOTH - lots of ways to hide the TV, suggest fire proof mantel under TV and out 6 inches or so to deflect heat away from face of wall/TV. and keep fireplace low - lots of ways to do this - to have comfortable viewing angle. Close TV when company comes - not a distraction, open when the game starts? - Best of both!
micknmina
7 years ago
Ohfergoshsakes. What works for you & your home layout? There are no hard & fast rules. The fireplace surround at our house in a open living space with windows all along one wall facing the lake is dark to camouflage the TV over the fireplace. The rest of the room is a cool beige. Art flanks them both, occupies the facing wall, & kitchen/dining space. I can work in the kitchen & still see nightly news. We don't sit right on top of the TV (buy big enough or go low) in a truncated couch & there is seating close to the fireplace as well. The gallery room showcases the larger art collection & the piano as guests come in the front door. Live optimally in your space & leave others to optimize theirs judgement free.
PRO
Sarita Simpson Design
7 years ago
In this project I separated the television and fireplace within the same space. I believe the design emphasizes the continuity of space for a loft-like environment.

Minimalist Modern Renovation · More Info

Check out my website!
Dana Veach
6 years ago
I'm late to the party on this thread, but wanted to weigh in on the value of fireplaces or wood stoves in a home in the first place. Not all of us live in the city or in suburbia, and there are those of us who heat our homes with wood out of necessity, and not for mere aesthetic reasons. The T.V. is utilized in our home only for watching videos...either for education or entertainment purposes. (I will not watch commercial T.V. any more.) So the T.V. gets its own spot on a wall opposite the fireplace. If I had a fireplace of an appropriate design, I wouldn't mind mounting the T.V. above it and covering it with a movable piece of artwork as a previous poster suggested. I'd rather situate it to one side, however, if at all possible so that I can view both!
misscorl1
6 years ago
If you are a purely functional driven person , its an obvious choice. If you are visual & strive to create a unique look in your home, it is not an appealing option.
ootockalockatuvik_7a
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
Against. Throw in some 3-D viewing glasses and you all look like a bunch of idiots watching a solar eclipse. The mantel is for seasonal decorations, not upward TV viewing.
PRO
Danniels-French Design
6 years ago
@misscorl1 - what is it that you feel is functional about a TV over a fireplace? Can't be the viewing angel as that's all wrong, as is usually the proper viewing distance. So in my opinion this is not a functional place to put the TV.

And it certainly is not a pleasing look unless you are able to hide it. ootockalockatuvik_7a is correct in that the mantle - if there is one, is a place for decorative items, though not just seasonal. If no mantle then the wall above should be nicely decorated with art, mirror etc.

A fireplace with or without a mantle (as so many of the newer linear ones give different options) is a focal point and should be pleasing to look at. It's so much nicer to spend time in a room that is well laid out, functional and nicely appointed. Keep in mind that when the TV is off - it's just a black hole.

For those who want to hide the TV, have a look at the new Samsung Frame TV - such a brilliant idea!

The debate goes on!
misscorl1
6 years ago
@Danniels-French Design. Allow me to clarify my comment, as I believe you've misunderstood my meaning ... I would never have a television over a fireplace mantel (unless there was absolutely no other option and I would hide it for the exact reasons you've mentioned).

I am an extremely visual person ,not everybody is visual. People who are less motivated by style or aesthetics (ie...more oriented to the functional aspects, tend to place their televisions on a main wall in the room , they spend the most time. Function over form.

My comment was on different motivations ...so no need to lecture as you're preaching to the choir :-)
PRO
Danniels-French Design
6 years ago
@misscorl1 - my apologies for missing your preference! Regardless, I still do not see it as functional unless people like a sore neck!! Or I guess they have nice recliners or theater seats that somewhat help. :-)
PRO
Mark Bischak, Architect
3 years ago
I vote for having the TV in the fireplace.

I love old threads.
Michele
3 years ago
Tee hee.
L W
3 years ago
Against! Even if you could move the TV down to a comfortable viewing level (using a narrow profile gas fireplace) the heat emitted can't be good for the set. As they say, that's a "hard no".
Laura Carver
2 years ago
Bought a new build with tv over fireplace. TV became damaged from very limited fireplace use over 4 years
Win
2 years ago
My neck is hurting thinking about the tv over the fireplace!
Toronto Veterinarian
2 years ago
Against -- but I also wouldn't put the TV where it is in the photo. That's a ridiculously useless spot - if you're going to watch TV, put it somewhere useful.
2_dogsenough
4 months ago
Samsung Frame TV was our compromise. I don't feel, as many do, that one gets extra "high ground" points for not having a tv at all; watching is something that our family enjoys doing together. We've got an electric fireplace, a mantel for decorating as the season suggests, and changeable art above. Win/win/win.

Design Debate: Are you FOR or AGAINST hanging a TV over a fireplace?

Comments (133)

Related Discussions

COMPANY

EXPLORE HOUZZ

CONNECT WITH US